Skip to content
Insights

From Carbon to Cobalt: The Biggest Shift in Energy History

20/03/2025

In Economy, Energy, Infrastructure, Investment, Net Zero, Politics, Regulation

By Harry Shackleton

From Carbon to Cobalt: The Biggest Shift in Energy History

Watching the daily psychodrama unfolding over the pond is another reminder of how the post-war political consensus no longer holds and holds up a mirror to how the world has changed. It’s not just about populism or the power of social media, but the fundamental drivers of the world economy and geopolitics have changed, and without most people realising it.

For over a century, energy markets have been defined by fuels. Coal, oil, and gas — dug, drilled, and burned — have powered the world’s economy, dictated geopolitics, shaped global supply chains and pumped billions of tonnes of global warming gases into the atmosphere.

However, the energy transition is rewriting the rulebook, and the age of fuel-based energy is giving way to an era where minerals hold the keys to power.

This shift is more than just a technological upgrade; it’s a fundamental reordering of how energy is sourced, stored, and supplied. And for investors, policymakers, and businesses, the consequences are enormous.

The Fuels Era: Extraction, Consumption, and Dependence

For decades, the energy market operated on a simple cycle: extract, refine, burn, repeat. Fossil fuels were the dominant commodity, and economies ran on a pipeline of continuous consumption. This model made energy a constant cost, with supply chains built around a perpetual need for extraction.

Oil companies became economic superpowers and petrostates wielded outsized geopolitical influence as everyone competed to secure access to finite and dwindling resources. It was a world of strategic reserves, price shocks, and energy security risks tied to a handful of producers.

This battle for resources has dominated geopolitics for more than a century. From Operation Barbarossa, to the Suez Crisis, the 1979 oil crisis or the 2003 invasion of Iraq, access to fossil fuels has shaped the modern world.

But now, as green technologies and electrification gather pace, driven by the existential threat of climate change, the global energy value chain is changing — moving away from combustibles and towards minerals.

The Minerals Era: Batteries, Storage, and Scarcity

Unlike fossil fuels, renewable energy sources don’t need to be continuously extracted and burned, breaking our dependence on fossil fuels and the historic energy market.

However, the wind does not always blow, and the sun does not always shine, so the energy produced needs to be stored and transported, and that’s where critical minerals come in.

In this new energy economy, the dash for minerals has become the new imperative.

Minerals such as Lithium (the backbone of battery storage and essential for EVs and grid-scale storage) or Cobalt & Nickel (vital for battery cathodes), Copper (key to expanding electrification) and a bunch of rare earth elements you’ve probably never heard of (Praseodymium, anyone?) are now in global demand.

These materials aren’t burned, but embedded in infrastructure — in batteries, solar panels, wind turbines, and electric grids. Energy investment is shifting from fuel supply chains (which require constant replenishment) to hardware supply chains (which require upfront investment but last decades).

Minerals are shifting geopolitics

The move from fuels to minerals means that energy is shifting from an unavoidable cost to an asset class, and one that is attracting the eyes of global investors and nations alike.

For the last 50 years, the global energy market has revolved around Middle Eastern oil, Russian gas, and American shale. Now, it’s shifting toward South American lithium, Indonesian nickel, and Chinese rare earths.

Access to these minerals has caused shifts in the foreign policy of the global superpowers, as critical minerals are concentrated in a few key regions, so securing access to mineral deposits and refining capacity is the new focus.

The US’s shift to insistence on a minerals deal with Ukraine in exchange for security guarantees should be seen in this light, Ukraine has Europe’s largest lithium reserves, which are largely untapped, and is responsible for 7% of global titanium production alongside substantial graphite reserves.

However, the US is not alone; China’s Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) is deeply connected to its strategic need for access to critical minerals, and the countries where it has invested have significant mineral deposits. The Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC) holds the world’s largest cobalt reserves, Indonesia is a key supplier of nickel, and the area between Argentina, Bolivia, and Chile is known as the “Lithium Triangle”. The BRI not only exchanges infrastructure investment for mineral rights, but the very infrastructure that China is building (roads and railways) is also crucial to transport those minerals to where they are needed.

What This Means for Investors and Policymakers

We are already seeing the shifts from this change to our energy demands, but there is much more to come. Countries and companies that control mineral extraction and processing will shape the future of energy, and economic growth will follow. 

The next energy superpowers won’t be those with the most fossil fuel reserves, but those with the best renewable infrastructure, battery technology, and mineral supply chains. Countries that don’t have access to these resources will be dependent on trade and fluctuations in global prices.

From resource nationalism (countries restricting exports of critical minerals) to industrial policy (governments investing in domestic supply chains), access to minerals will be a key factor in domestic and international politics over the decades to come.

The Future: A New Energy Paradigm

The transition from fuels to minerals isn’t just a shift in commodities—it’s a transformation of the global energy system. For businesses and investors, this means rethinking how energy is valued, secured, and supplied.

Energy is no longer something we burn and replace; it’s something we build and optimise. And as this transition accelerates, the companies and countries that adapt fastest will define the next century of global power.Find Out More About Our Work On Net Zero

Insights

View all
Talk to us